We have a Master from Fate/Samurai Remnant as a Servant, so we could have Shirou as a Servant. Besides, I didn't make this tier list, so I have no idea why Shirou and Shinji are here.
Atp, can't we just summon regular humans as servants, like Shirou?
The Mahoyo trio pretty much showed up by themselves, no body possession.
I think there's always room for FSN Shirou to join at some point.
@Muhammad Abdul Aziz Habibi I don't forget Lady Kasuga, I wish she was the Lancer Class Servant or costume dress for Parvati.
Mahoyo characters are the way they are because they're pulled from 'end' of Mahoyo.
Aoko's Foreigner class was speculated to be indication she'll be survivor of the series (alongside Tohko), as Nasu didn't deny Soujurou's NP is based on his final moment on future Mahoyo chapter.
Iori is similar. His playable FGO ver. is based on Sam-Rem route where he died.
So its not like they pulled everyone, saying 'screw rules', it works because TM knew Mahoyo characters, Iori and Yui do met requirements to be summoned in future.
Pulling Shirou from FSN is tough work because every route where he died always he died before reaching his full potential. If he fully realized his potential before he died, then its one-way trip to EMIYA. So do if you wanted Rin and Sakura from FSN thus pseudos for them. Your best bet are Shirou, Rin and Sakura from Prisma Illya.
I think she needs to be a separate servant. Kasuga and Parvati could be a good parent for Kama.
@Muhammad Abdul Aziz Habibi I completely agree with you, it would be a good solution, if Lady Kasuga were the Servant, I would immediately summon and start grailing to level 100.
@Valeth I don't buy that logic. You'll need a lot of your speculation to perfectly align in reality to justify bringing in the Mahoyo characters, at least.
There can always be parallel worlds similar to the FSN timeline that can facilitate Shirou coming in.
Shiki and Fujino come to mind, back from their original event. They're not from the exact same setting as the Light Novels and Movies, but pretty much the exact same characters.
Like I said, there's always room.
Redheads and bare midriffs... (눈_눈)
My list will have Mr Molay on top, with Zeus/Han Xin in Tier A below(both of them are almost bullied by Lassengle, isolated, ignored, all of their other colleagues had been implemented! Let them have some goodies, for god sake)
and Shinji(more importantly, c.v. Kamiya. I will take other Kamiya voiced characters too) and Ryuunosuke(the same. I just want some c.v. Ishida characters) in my tier A.
For Rikyuu-and-Chen reasons, I will appreciate Hideyoshi too. Fireworks for Koma.
And I will be fairly happy if Ramesses has something to say about Moses, but if not I don't really care.
The rest... I don't really care at all. To me people like Jeanne in F/SR are just another Jeanne, and we have Jeanne already. I would rather see some new faces, especially some new faces that can be related to existing characters. As I said before there are miles of famous historical figures queueing, Ludwig the former-Napoleon-fanboy, Houdini the spiritual-mythbuster...and on the other hand, Bradamante is still looking for her boyfriend, Doman his rival.
Oh yes. and Perseus, who had been waiting since Proto era! His wife will be happy if he is here too.
Why did you bother to create a tier for characters that you dont care about 😭
What do you think?