Their tier list is wildly inconsistent. There's rarely a consensus between the group of people voting in it. There are even examples when one gives a servant an A and someone else gives them a D. Because of this, meta supports are the only ones who ever seem to get EX. So I'd say EX-.

@Astolfø (you have no idea how hard it is to tag you given how many Astolfos there are lol) I don't really see a problem with Kama, she is in my "really good" category, so going by their system, is somewhere between A and EX.

Yu has a targetable NP Charge in addition to a steroid and survival, so she is a bit of a cut above the rest, and funny enough, Artemis is lower tiered because Euryale exists lol (even tho they cover different grounds). That said, I wouldn't go above A- going by their system since it sells the rest short, but close enough, hence why I say, it works as a reference.

Douman is a lot of fun, allows for shenanigans, can't say much about where to put him, but he does have a 80% battery, so that coupled with his other effects is at least B+ imo.

As for Paracelsus, they probably made the list based on the rarity (as they have seperate 1-3, 4 an 5 servant lists), so going by the 1-3 system, he is a really useful servant, especially to those that lack Castoria. It's when you overlap all the tier lists you see that he kinda mixes in with the REALLY good ones.

What??? Douman is amazing. And...god tier husbando. I use him all the time in farming and boss fights.

Doesn't really matter tbh, because GP tierlists are a joke, it's not a good reference to decide which servants you should invest in.

I'd disagree, they're pretty accurate on what you can expect from a servant, you just need to see what you need based on what you have.

That said, once you gain experience as a player, you see all servants as equal chess pieces.

The actual question is: "Why is an internet ranking of any significance to you?" in a game where almost anything works so it's a matter of "who do you like using" rather than "is this unit meta"...

A better tier list would be one that ranks servants based on their niche e.g. farmers, supports, single target, solo unit etc.

Its hard when you group every servant when they all do something different. You can sort them by card type and AoE, ST and support NPs but I still find it needs more nuance

A+ plus cause game weird.

@XYukix3 I would love some games or anime where Douman is Protagonist as I always liked him. As he is just ancient version Kato Yasunori.

I never said Kama was bad.

Yu having a taregtable charge is like, absolutely meaningless because the only person she will likely target with it is herself. With that said, Euryale also has a charge with drain and a steroid as well sooooooo.... And survival isn't even a problem for Euryale because if you are using her, it's probably against a man who will be charmed for like half his turns. And obviously Artemis is not good. I didn't imply she was good.

I never said Douman was bad. I simply said that I have never seen anyone use this guy and honestly if you think about it, my statement holds merit. Most players use double cas spish. Douman simply has no place on that team. And again, if somebody had double cas spish, they wouldn't even bother with him so if YOU are using him you probably dont have a double cas anything setup. Also I feel like the majority of the playerbase are men who probably don't want to roll for a half naked dude who neutral expression looks like hes into cock and ball torture.

And yes your bit about Paracelsus is... we'll leave it at "mostly true". But they gave the option to include all rarities in the same list so....

You'd be surprised. The thing that most of the players are male and they are not as willing to roll for male servants is absulotly true, though.

And yeah, I do have both Castoria and Spishtar (grailed one) so Castoria/Spishtar and Skadi/Douman are the teams I'm using the most.