Talk:Halloween 2015 Event Re-Run Lite Ver/@comment-111.95.105.109-20161013125859/@comment-27408750-20161013143244

The 40 AP Maid Cat's Hidden Room, the free quest with Tamamo Cat, is best for pumpkins, and also gives a good number of bats and candles. The 30 AP Throne of the Impaling Lord, the free quest with Vlad, is best for bats and candles. The 20 AP Hall of the Cleaning Queen, the free quest with Carmilla, gives a decent number of candles. The10 AP Gates of the Dancing Girl, the free quest with Mata Hari, gives out mostly cupcakes.

I'd focus more on the 30 AP and 40 AP, though, and then just trade in bats and pumpkins, once you buy those items requiring them out of the shop, for cupcakes. The trade is favorable to collect a lot of pumpkins and bats and then convert them into cupcakes in this event.

In the shop exchange:

1 pumpkin = 50 cupcakes

1 bat = 5 cupcakes

1 candle = 2 cupcakes

As you can see, it behooves you to horde pumpkins and turn them into cupcakes instead of farming cupcakes directly.