Talk:Servant Strengthening Quests Part VIII/@comment-99.250.107.102-20180304190141/@comment-33596150-20180305065147

@opAnon

another reason you see Jack all the time because if anyone has Jack and Carmilla at the same time, they might pick the highest cost one to put on the roster

@Durendal Albrecht

sorry if I overdescribed Carmilla before. I didn't mention Merlin at all in my argument, honestly I avoid mentioning him anywhere lol. there are many non-caster sources of buster buff around as you already know. her cardset even suggests you not to use too many buster buff. and I'm not talking about party setup here, but their individual quality as anti-female.

first let's compare their NP damage (at NP1 OC1 vs female): Jack is 1400%*1.5*0.8=1680% while Carmilla is 800%*1.5*1.5=1800%. but since Carmilla's max atk is 2000 points lower than Jack's, Carmilla of course will deal less damage theoretically. both has way of increasing NP damage, Jack is higher at 50% for 1 turn while Carmilla is only 20-40% for 3 turns.

in terms of NP gain and star gen, Carmilla behaves similarly to Jack with lower output probably due to lower base atk stat and hit count. but to cover that part, Carmilla has vampirism and blood bath which gives stars even if you don't use your quick cards. Carmilla can heal almost as much as Jack without cooldown though limited only for herself.

of course Jack would still win anyway because she has buff removal, defense ignoring NP, and evade (that is never actually used for evasion purpose) over Carmilla. she deserves it because she has 1 more star than Carmilla, not entirely because she deals more damage against female.