Talk:Ryougi Shiki (Saber)/@comment-112.215.244.240-20180214175946/@comment-30522333-20180218160557

That's the difference between evaluating a servant based on STATS and Pure Atk Stats. The former is harder but will give a more accurate evaluation of said servant as a whole; whereas the latter is easier but will give a simplified evaluation.

It's like judging a basketball player based on their height while stripping everything else about the player, such as their skills and speed.

Pandora's box is only open when we start considering team composition, and that's due to broken support servants like Merlin/Waver (with a lesser extend to Mashu and Tamamo). But even that can be restrained to an extent if we set up certain rules before the discussion.