Talk:Murder at the KOGETSUKAN/@comment-27353698-20180517041945

OK fine it was Harriet, I guessed Dorthy and was wrong. I'm pretty much satisfied by the explanation, though I think it's unfair that the chart was wrong after it seemed to be confirmed (without any open doubt from Holmes or Moriarty.)

The one thing I can't accept though is....WHO GAVE THE PROTAGANIST THE SLEEPING PILL!? If it was Harriet then why? To have him take the fall? It seems out of character that after doing all of that for her daughter and then condemn the one she loved. This was the main reason I eliminated Eve (who I thought was the actual mom.) So I'm kind of sour that there's no answer to this.

All that said I did really enjoy the event and thinking about it.