Talk:Servant Strengthening Quests Part VIII/@comment-34539796-20180304145818/@comment-29893250-20180304183508

Maid alter is so so. She's not really strong. Several easy reasons. 1. She's quick, the weakest card in the game without Jack hit counts/np gain/star gen. 2. She can potentially boost herself quite high for some massive hit but that's only with a huge amount of setup and will do much less than a NPBB chain. 3. Her NP isn't that spammable on her own due to her passabe but not amazing NP gain. Her base damage output is low in combination with being a quick servants.

When I looked at her on paper first before they mined out her NP gain, I assumed that they were going to make her spam like Squirtoria. Her set looks like she's meant for it. However, she's a couple notches short of being able to do that. I do have her and can safely say that the two are like night and day. She's not horribad but she's no Ozy or Quetz.

I will say, though, that people saying she's like a 4 star are probably spoiled by Kintoki rider basically being like a 5 star. Btw, yes, he is better than maid alter. I think this even applies to them at equal NP levels just because Kintoki can chain spam consistently and maid alter generally can't. She can sometimes fire twice in a row if you set her up right but her NP gain is... well... like HALF of what his is on quicks and still lower on arts.