Talk:Mysterious Heroine X (Alter)/@comment-125.207.180.40-20170406210700/@comment-28209103-20170416024702

It's not that massive, really. I tested NP 4 and at best she hit around 250k on saber.. my NP 1 dealt around 150k to saber with JAlter buff, same level as MHX vs Saber Artoria. this is where I made my mistake before on Carmilla, they did not add 150% damage but rather multiply it by 1.5 (50%), add to the fact her class only give you 1.5 extra vs Saber it means that Archer 2x multiplier are similar if not superior, at the very least they don't take double damage from Saber.

You're forgetting the star distribution mechanic. as I said there's hidden weight mechanism behind star absorb and it's attached to cards rather than servant. The additional weight are 20 20 and 50 while the other have 0 weight bonus, and going by your scenario the only way for XAlter to get the stars are when all of her 3 cards coincidentally have additional weight in them, otherwise if even single card of JAlter landed on that bonus slot then some stars gonna stray to her.. basically RNG could screw you.

I don't really reccomend MHXA as crit hitter, but I do reccomend her as crit supporter, especially with JAlter,, even without crit a 60% atk boosted Zerker hit hard. If you must use her as crit hitter use that Daba whatever (GilxEnkidu) on her, at the very least that'll give her an edge on the situation you mentioned tho it's not that signfinicant of a boost since the star weight didn't even went beyond 50. if you wanted a crit zerk go and take Raikou, Lancelot or to some extend Hijikata,,