Talk:EMIYA/@comment-120.188.35.88-20180228135059/@comment-34208015-20180504063602

@Valeth: If you can't see where lie the flaw having at the same time skill that boost star gen and triple A deck unable to generate star most the time. I stated my point quite clear enough to explain why I think Emiya's deck is suboptimal to exploit Hawkeye. Once again it's not about if Emiya is good or not but if he could have been better or at least better match between his skill set and deck.

For the jack-of-all-trade part I'm still waiting you guys to explain me what clear role Emiya can fill beside damage dealer, he already can't be a main star engine so what next? His NP debuff is too weak to be significant alone so you have to complete it with servant that can reduce damage further like Mashu, Waver or Munenori (that by the way doesn't really need Emiya support) that's why I said he's a specialized tool and not a jack-of-all-trades. It's not like I wanted Okita being a jack-of-all-trades but she indeniably is because of her Quick nature, her balanced Quick/Buster deck and high generation capability: She can fill several role in the same run.

Once again I think you're not working on the same level, I'm commenting on the team level (what role can he fill in a team) while you're at the competence level (what kind of skill/effect does have the servant).