Talk:Fate/Grand Order Fes. 2018 ～3rd Anniversary～/@comment-26353030-20180730192204

Trying to decide which paid gacha to choose. Everyone seems to be recommending the Extra gacha, but I'm also thinking of the Assassin one, and to a lesser extent, the Caster one.

The thing is, if I roll the Assassin gacha, there's a 4 in 7 chance of getting someone I want (Osakabe, Jack, Shuten, or Gramps). I'm not gonna lie, I'd be a bit disappointed if I got Cleopatra or MHX, but that wouldn't be the end of the world either. The worst thing that could happen would be getting a Semiramis dupe, but that's just a 1 in 7 chance.

The Extra gacha, on the other hand, offers a 30% chance of getting one of the limited Servants that I'd really appreciate (Jalter, Abby, or Hokusai). However, there's also a 30% chance of getting a duplicate of Sherlock, Melt, or Edgemond, as well as an additional 20% chance of getting a disappointing Servant like Kiara or Amakusa. The Caster gacha is similarly high-risk, high-reward; sure, I might get Waver or Merlin, but I might also end up simply raising my Tamamo to NP4, or worse, getting Scheherazade.

So, should I go for the Extra gacha anyway, or should I play it safe and go for Assassins? Or maybe I should take a risk and go for those OP Caster supports? Any tips would be appreciated. :)