Talk:"The Old Man of the Mountain"/@comment-50.71.60.33-20180213041407/@comment-34208015-20180226080743

No that not what I said at all. What I said is that both theorical calculation and pratical testing should confort themselves. If you got results too far away it means that somethng is wrong. It can be either theorical said: miscalculation, formula error... or pratical side: human errors (typically you didn't noticed that you got Overkill or forgot it) can easy happens espically in such non-formal context. That's why I said using calculator is not wrong, trusting blind is. But the same goes for pratical experiments: doing them is not wrong, but trusting them blind is. Theorical calculation and testing are complementary not exclusive.

How can someone know such untold convention about hit = card on a game that feature both?

I wouldn't be surprise considering the crit and the Atk Up buff stack and the Buster opener bonus that KH hit 12~13k per hit in your example. That's why I ask you once again. Are you sure there was no Overkill mark before the first Extra card's hit? As I said this is the typical mistakes or rather unprecision that can distort the conclusions of an experiment.