Talk:Scáthach/@comment-40203888-20190724144741/@comment-27971189-20190725120238

If you really insists about the meaning of shadow. Why not just quote the book source together with its explanation that tied both, instead of Wikipedia, it will be more believable like that.

Mind that this is no different than Lorfram asking you about "what is your proof for that trivia" as he's not convinced ...then what he got as answer is Wikipedia page supporting how it uncertain; he's not telling you rewriting all Norse and Irish myth, simply what is your proof. To be fair, if Lakshmibai page can have book reference, why not with this?

As far "IMO" argument goes. Scat-hach on Irish part AFAIK is clear enough it serves part to define she's ruler of the land of shadows. However the argument fall in convincing that Skadi possess same meaning as, even Wikipedia page you use as reasoning wrote "uncertain".

Its simple. No need to bring murderer as they did nothing between you.