Talk:Mysterious Heroine X (Alter)/@comment-180.190.35.116-20180210113516/@comment-86.26.242.62-20180211133026

They fill different roles.

Nightingale is better as a support (4000 HP and 3000 HP heal on her first skill and NP, and 50% Buster boost for 3 turns are great,) and survives longer, but naturally being a zerker she can't be the sustainable support you get from a lot of the Caster pool.

MHXA's excellent offensively but is toothpick fragile. She has some of the best star gen in the game and can actually generate NP reliably because the NP gen on her quicks are awesome. She's no good for things like challenge quests though - she dies way too quickly.