Talk:Karna/@comment-28136716-20171222092729/@comment-28136716-20171228150749

Whoa whoa whoa, didn't think my comment would ignite this. Please chill guy.

IMO Gil is not a Gary Stu because we all can agree how much of an asshole he is. Ofc he has all the rights to be so but assholes are assholes nonetheless. His arrogance really got him killed more than once. If Gil has the power at his zenith from his Archer version plus the personality from his shota and Caster version, only then he is qualified as a Gary Stu, at least for me.

As for Karna, he is pure husbando material. His history is glorious. I'm not  saying he is stronger than Gil but we all know he is on AuO's tier, that much would say how OP he is. And if you have watched and played through all adaptations that present him (Extra, Extella, Apocrypha and even this very FGO) you will surely know that he comes second only to Jeanne in terms of personality.

That's why he is the one true Gary Stu for me.

And when I posted this I almost forgot there's also Ozy too. The three of them kinda tip the balance scale in whichever HGW they are presented in but personally I found Ozy and Karna to be much more likeable.