Talk:King Hassan/@comment-36.81.58.88-20170115133232/@comment-27971189-20170117183234

Saying veteran miss Carmilla is an understatement.

Sure Carmilla may dish more damage against female. But with Jack simply being Jack, she can NP spam with no problem while also support party, something that Carmilla have hard time to do. The best she can do to keep herself alive is NP Drain while Jack have Dodge and Heal. In casual team build, against Jack, Carmilla is facing a battle she can't win even on NP 5.

IMO, the comparison is not butcher knife against regular knife, but butcher knife against Sword of Promised Victory. You can support butcher knife with magecraft, but in front of Excalibur, its just miss something even on same A++ rank.

Its not like veteran forgot them, but veteran will always put those who can fit on casual team easily on higher tier when making assessment, as it tend to be used as recommendation to casual players. If FGO is never casual to begin with, everyone will promote Asterios as Best Zerker instead of Cu and Raikou.

They still recommend Carmilla, only the recommendation will lean toward "Against female Rider", more specific than Jack who could get "Against those that's not Caster, especially female".