Talk:Fūma Kotarō/@comment-30480779-20161210234340/@comment-30480779-20161211190936

Sure, Jack is better in a vacuum where party composition isn't a factor, but the fact that a 7 cost servant can be seriously compared to a 16 cost servant should tell you something. For less than half the cost, I get a servant with better utility and comparable, if lesser, star gen, which means I can use better CEs on him and the rest of my party. (He's also not totally creepy.)

Theory also has absolutely nothing to do with servant attainability. Jack the Stripper is a 5*, and a fraction of 1% to obtain from gacha. Scathach (Assassin) was an event limited from before I started playing. Atalanta is the only servant you mentioned I even have a realistic shot at obtaining (besides Cursed-Arm Hassan, who can be NP5'd after a couple weeks of FP gacha), and she's a 4* Archer, and could never replace an Assassin in fights against Riders.

It's good to sign the praises of your waifus, but I've been using Fuuma Kotarou with a max-LB Holy Night Sign (as seen in the screenshot), and there's nobody I'm going to replace him with any time soon. (My basic party setup is him, Nero Bride, and Francis Drake, and those two were my only 5*s until very recently. Why change what works?)