Talk:Atalanta/@comment-96.255.136.9-20180303023646/@comment-34484799-20180317124929


 * SPOILER* wish people would bother including SPOILER tag in their spoiler comments, mine is a spoiler so feel free to ignore this is you don't want to be spoiled!

You do remember that she didn't know Jack was a child right? As soon as she got close enough to see, you could clearly see the shock on her face upon realizing that she shot a child even though that child was a servant. Also Jack and her master were targeting civilians and were danger that needed to be dealt with, the entire mission in those two episodes was specifically to kill Jack because she was such a loose cannon. You can't really pin the blame on Atalanta for that one because they were all after Jack and after realizing Jack was a child, she freaked out and tried to save to her but Jeanne purified her and finished her off causing Atalanta to have a massive grudge and resentment for her, Also pretty sure it was really foggy at the time so Nyanta had to close the distance to get a good view of Jack,

Jack's information erasure might have played a part in keeping Nyanta from seeing her clearly from a distance. All she felt was the presence of the Servant that was killing humans that weren't involved in the war so she took the shot, plus Jack was already attacking both factions so it was a perfectly valid reason to deal with her as she was a very dangerous threat. Just like with Fran and Mordred, I can't fault Mordred for Fran's death because they were both fighting in a war for the grail and Mordred just clearly outmatched her, that's all there is to it.