Talk:A Study in the Dubious Meiho-sou/@comment-32856683-20190521165720/@comment-29547051-20190522001959

Can't say this was a total letdown. It certainly had it's Engaging experience with those of us that wanted a good mystery solving experience. If I had to rate my best between the Kogetsu event and this one, I would say the previous one deserves the best marks because of all the clues that were laid out before us and most of us managed to solve it (thanks to the helpful minds of players and the fast Reddit translations). There was a sense of achievements with that one, so I was feeling really good after getting it right.

-This one was a little bit of a tougher side since the "mystery murder" was taking this whole event outside of the box without giving away any important clues as to what really happened. Imagine that there was no final solution and that we had to narrow down the possibilities that the servants were giving us. That on it's own is certainly an ingenious way of stirring up the community towards finding the right possible answer with what we were given. As Valeth has stated in the previous comment, this was a very good game feel strategy (can't say marketing since that relies on advertising side of their product) and without a doubt turned out to be successful in it's own way. But unfortunatly, we had our objectives mixed up to where we wanted to find out who poisoned Gabriella, but instead it was to vote on the servants senario ending. As the fan favorite of Umineko Dschehuti had stated, it felt like a big slap to the face on players that were trying to actually solve the real mystery of the story instead of favortism voting. While the whole thing took a turn to that scenario (thanks to a few curve balls by the event), it was pretty decent to know that we all worked well in gathering what we knew and narrowed down the possibilities presented to us.

-I voted for JAlter BEFORE the early-poll voting came out, so I can honestly say that I stuck with the favorite crowd. But it would've been nice if there was a possible final solution to this hectic mystery.