Talk:William Tell/@comment-33784096-20190620045938/@comment-4802891-20190620071011

1. Firepower might increase, but the sure-hit ability is inherent to him. In a normal HGW his Master would probably give him firearms to hide his idendity, but the crossbow is part of his Saint Graph. Similar case with Proto Cu.

2. Potentially but he probably wouldn't use any. This cannon is the crystallization of his symbol as the Man of Possibilities, just like Rule Breaker exemplifies Medea's treacherous nature. None of these ever existed, especially not with the properties they are given here.

3. If the ability said he could disarm anybody, and it was such a unique trait it is turned into a Noble Phantasm, then he would be able to disarm Noble Phantasms too. That said, it probably wouldn't be "that" strong since these weapons are tied to a Servant's Saint Graph. I think it would end up like Izou's Shimatsuken on copying techniques; the martial artist would be able to at least take the Servant off-guard, and get an opportunity to score a deadly hit.

Now that this is said, FGO has a case of many different people designing Servants. Some like to stick to the roots, some like to go beyond these limitations, some are creative enough to portray things in a flashier way, or inscribe a character into the world itself (which can go too far, I agree). That allows for a wide variety of cases, and the only problem I see is that they unavoidably clash.

While some things feel asspulled even in the diegesis of Fate (like Jinako being a Mooncancer), aren't we there to have fun? Are the artists not allowed to have their share too?