Talk:Christmas 2017 Event (US)/@comment-73.137.138.226-20171205043211/@comment-100.8.53.203-20171205112330

@OP We need to factor in your party here. Let's say you've got E-rank luck like me and have to use non-gold Servants: David-Caesar-Jing Ke-Darius-Robin Hood. You already have a +5 bonus. If you add your bonus Servant Jack (I think only she gives a bonus 3), you've got a total of bonus 8.

Holy Night Sign is a bit trickier since it goes by chance. Also bear in mind that even if you're lucky enough to get the bonus, drop, the drop may have a different base value than the original drop (however, you are still guaranteed your bonus 5 socks from your original party).

My bonus drops tend to have a base value of 4, but that's not universal. Nevertheless, it does edge out the bonus of your Jack.

It's simple math, right? 4 is more than 3, so go with the Holy Night Sign. However, the real question is whether or not RNGesus will have mercy on you and let the drop happen.

It's a matter of whether or not you want to take chances. My advice is to go with Jack, not only because the Socks are guaranteed, but because many people are so hyped about the bonuses that they forget that they need to actually CLEAR the quest to get drops. If your party's too low-level, use Jack over Holy Night Sign. I'd say bother switching out Jack for a Holy Night Sign Support once you have all 4 of them from your Store, but I can stomach doing so if you buy out 3.

Good luck!