User blog comment:Valeth/The Not-So-Helpful FGO's SSR Guide (JP)/@comment-37413228-20190301115425/@comment-27971189-20190301150000

I tried so this list updated following new Servants, strengthening; enemies we, players, met on Story Mode and Interlude (no CQ or Event), so placements is temporary following how DW did meta--this game is single player game after all.

About Kingprotea, I think Hikaru already wrote the easiest way of telling it.

What you got from her is utility of sledgehammer, not more, not less; which, in my opinion is nothing "special" compare to other AEs and Horsemen in general. As I ran her under support slot with rag-tag allies, I personally not experiencing anything worth my Quartz as well.

NP Charge per HP stack is nice, allow you to end whenever you consider dangerous.

However you may consider she 'wasted' it at NP 1 as she bring AAQBB deck, gain enough from crits, and most likely survive through 5 turns due to Horsemen's average NP tick are 4. Unless complete buff removal involved, at worst you may get about 2 or 3 stack.

Think of it like ... the real benefit of second skill goes to NP 2 or more where you can aim overcharge freely, no need worrying about CD while also going turtle team with her--surely overcharge is not mandatory to do.

That said, I won't consider what she offers as some kind of high-class feature-- meanwhile all other AE able to access advantages since first turn.

Regarding comparison with Okita Alter, I'd say it down to 'which one you prefer, easy ones or hard ones'. With Kingprotea, you can access high damage relatively ease. With Okita Alt; the access to high damage may be difficult but its worth the effort as Buster reduction is nice feat.

One reason why I consider Okita Alter above her is due to how her Buster reduction allowing good team advantages while she does not interrupting star-distribution, unlike Ivan, her 'only' substitute among Horsemen-- as well as compensating NP 1; you also can jumpstart the debuff + high crit from her with her second skill, nice advantage, need starting NP though.

If Lostbelt IV bring more Horsemen with debuff immune, no update from DW, while Kingprotea bruteforce method proven to be effective even at NP 1 + frontline + no support involved. I will promote her. For now, Okita Alter still better pick when it comes to 'value'.