Talk:Frankenstein/@comment-112.215.241.3-20170718175157/@comment-47.186.96.208-20171213172011

I want to point out a few things:

1st of all, the reason the Grail would kill millions of people for Kiritsugu's wish was more because it was already corrupted by Angra Mainyu from the 3rd Grail War. This is something specific to Fate/Zero and Fate/Stay Night; not sure if it applies in Apocrypha though. But basically, that specific Grail has been corrupted to answer every wish through violence. The only time when it doesn't do this and is still used is at the end of Heaven's Feel, which I won't spoil, but I will say that the person who did it knew enough about the Grail to take full control over it and supersede Angra Mainyu.

2nd, Fate/Grand Order is a special case. The Summoning System at Chaldea is explicitly weaker than most other systems, so all Servants it summons are invariably weaker than the other ones, but it also allows a Master to summon multiple Servants and allows for odd Servants that wouldn't normally be possible. This is why a bunch of post-American Revolution Servants are able to be summoned despite Fate/Stay Night explicitly saying it is more difficult for new heroes to reach Heroic Spirit level due to all the universal technology and the progressive weakening of magic. The Rules of the Throne of Heroes haven't changed much, but the different summoning systems ARE different. The original EMIYA Servant doesn't apply to this change, because of his status as Counter Guardian.

3rd, the Summoning System (all of them that I've seen in various Fate works) do NOT explicitly draw from our world. Fake Servants like Sasaki Kojirou DO exist, but there are also several Servants that come from parallel universes. For instance, the original EMIYA from Fate/Stay Night might not even have come from any of the Fate/Stay Night timelines; he says himself that this is possible, though his memory is corrupted enough that he isn't sure. Another example are the Fate/GO Servants Miyamoto Musashi and the Fate/Prototype Servants. Musashi has stated, for instance, that she doesn't recognize any of the Servants that she should have known in life. It is completely plausible that this Frankenstein's Monster is the version from, say, Apocrypha's world; I don't know if her Master ever acts confused because she's a girl, but if he does it could be that there was a real Mage who made her in that version of the world and that the book was only loosely based on her.