Talk:Artoria Pendragon (Rider Alter)/@comment-32751919-20170905060525/@comment-29726162-20170905132928

@Valeth

Drake>Maid Alter... Are you sure about that ? Basically, his NP gain is worst than Maid Alter, but her 4-hit Arts make this NP gain better than Maid Alter, so Drake>Maid Alter on that. Drake have just 650 more damages than her, but maid Alter have 1426 more hp (I'm speaking about max HP without grail), so at this Maid Alter>Drake. The first skill of Drake give her, at Lvl 10, 34% more damages on NP and 17 % to the team; The one of Maid Alter give her 50% on NP and 20% to the team on Quicks. Even if the team bonus is just for quicks, once again, Maid Alter>Drake. The second skill of Drake increase his own NP gain by 45%, which is pretty good but selfish, unfortunately. Maid Alter second skill is really good, not only because you can choose the ally which you give 50 %  of crit absorb, but honestly, because everyone someday fought a boss, and met the situation of "If this skill would have 1 less cooldown, this servant would survive/finish this battle". Choosing who's the best between their 2nd skill is subjective so I can't say which is better. Drake 3rd skill is the best she have: 50% of NP gauge+10 stars+Ignoring defense; In contrast, the 3rd skill of Maid Alter, is selfish and 30 % Quick is too weak for compensate it, so Drake>Maid Alter this time. Drake and Maid Alter have the same 1st and 2nd passives, but Maid Alter have 5% more debuff resistance and a 3rd skill of crit damages, so Maid Alter>Drake. Drake's NP touch all enemies with only 400 % (442 % with the first skill and the second passive), which is not really good, but this is a bit compensate by the generation of 20 stars. Maid Alter's NP touch one enemy with 1200 % (1288 % with 1st, 3rd skill and second passive), which is pretty good, and give to the enemy a crit debuff, so clearly Maid Alter>Drake on this.

Well, Drake is better for NP Gain, spam ability and 3rd skill. For everything else, Maid Alter is better. So for me, Maid Alter>Drake.