Talk:Servant Summer Festival! 2018 Rerun/@comment-39895801-20190728165843/@comment-28209103-20190729134418

If we disregard the Apocrypha references in which is still unclear as of now since I haven't read El Melloi case file due to detective fiction is not quite my cup of tea.. the world of El Melloi are supposed to happen between 4th and 5th Grail War that led to the ultimate conclusion where Waver dismantled the Great Grail.

To put it simply, Apocrypha happened in event on 3rd war where Einzbern decided to Cheat by summoning Ruler.

The world of El Melloi Case file, FSN and Hollow Atraxia happened when Einzbern decided to Cheat the 3rd war by summoning Avenger instead.

With exception of those divergence in key event and it's subsequent chain of event, most of the people living in there should generally be the same, e.g Bazett should also exist in Apocrypha even when author doesn't explicitly told us she exist.

--- Hence the existence of Gaulles,or Shishigo Kairi itself is not weird, the questionable one is the circumstances of how did Gaulles ended up in Waver class. Again since I haven't read the El Melloi case files LN I wouldn't have known under what circumstances does Gaulles to end up in El Melloi class but I assume there's this and that that reason led to that conclusion regardless of Apocrypha event.

At the very least it's easier to accept Gaulles in Waver class compared to Apocrypha lorefuck.. in there Waver somehow took the name of El Melloi II even tho the 4th war NEVER HAPPENED..

---

However as I said generally speaking using the word of the God (a.k.a Author a.k.a Mushroom man) from his own blog the world is basically just a set with some pre-existing character. They just thrown in new premise and put the character in there.

also another word of god is that the only read divide in Nasuverse is between Tsukihime and Fate.. however several new works kinda contradict that old blog.