Talk:New Year 2017 Summoning Campaign/@comment-4802891-20170106151344/@comment-29893250-20170106224756

Obviously he should choose the one he likes. While I don't think David is a good servant for black grail, I do believe he slots better into the team than Robin Hood which we agree on. However, I think you underestimate just how much Robin Hood has been nerfed. I believe that despite David being support, he will hit approximately as hard as Robin Hood.

1500%+250 (a 500% overcharge which is unlikely but the highest possible) x1 (arts multiplier) x 6715 (This is the real kicker. His attack is abysmal) +1000 for fous=  135,012.5

With a 100% overcharge, it is 131,115

1000% x1.5 x7736+1000 for fous x1.09 (Just level 1 charisma) = 142,883.6

Without charisma, it is 131,040

So their damage is just about equal without David having Charisma. With Charisma, David does more and helps the whole team do more. The difference will only widen as you give David a higher Charisma. Now, we do have to consider that Robin hood does have a NP gen+ skill and an arts NP vs David's 3 arts cards. So he will be able to fire off slightly more frequently than David. However, what makes David more viable for black grail is that his total NP damage output is at least equal to Robin Hood's (I'd say it'd be noticeably more) but he also supports better, hits harder from normal attacks, and basically ignores the kickback from black grail due to his healing skills, both small heal in healing harp and the healing from divine protection. This makes him last much, much longer than Robin Hood, helping him (and everyone else) live based on his own merits rather than chipping away at himself. Robin Hood does dock their attack somewhat but it isn't nearly equal to David's utility. It isn't that David is good for Black Grail. It is that Robin Hood got totally robbed ever since the fixed his bug. but never got fixed again to properly balance him and make up for what they took from him.