Talk:Mysterious Heroine X (Alter)/@comment-183.89.153.174-20170214045730/@comment-27971189-20170219151115

@ Velox

Mind you, enemies have different properties involved generating stars, which is why sometimes you lose stars you generate.

Against Babbage in her trial, I also do NP-Q-Q mind you, and since the CE you use not gave star-generation boost, means we're at equal on basis-- different only at enemies, yet different enemies lead to different result as well. What I got is no more than 20+ stars. No lies. Some players on other discussion gave similar result as well.

The difference of such result of could be caused because my enemies are non-Berserker, Servant while your enemies are Berserker, large one.

As mine is closer to general/casual use, I conclude that amount of stars is insufficient to maintain crits when you think the effort needed to fill her NP without charger; not everyone have charger or can always rely to Merlin and Waver; pretty much still saying. 'there's better Servant to do the job if you intend for support role of generating stars'.

The reason why I pushing 'she need stars' is because the reality that her normals are lackluster on terms of damage and she can't fill NP properly unless you pull a crits, yet if you could pull the crits, she is a good DPS and have no problem to reach 100% NP-- which is her selling point thanks to her hit counts. If you really test her throughly, how can you not see the difference between her crits and not?

This is reason why some communities made joke about Sovereign and her low star-absorption. Sovereign is intended to help her claim stars with Charisma to complement, yet her low star-absorption and RNG nature won't allow Sovereign to works properly, make it pointless on casual team build and her third skill is no different than usual Charisma.

Instinct tried to be the saving grace, yet the amount of stars given and how Sovereign not guarantee MHXA claim all low amount of stars in casual team made her rating inevitably low, which of course saying having a dedicated team is far better than having him outside being a main DPS in her own team.

You bring Dantes only confirmed you can have better Quick servant than MHXA as Dantes is Jack-of-All-Trades to begin with. You bring Mashu also confirmed- how fragile she is that she need further support to stand long compare to other Berserker. What is the difference again?