Talk:Instinct/@comment-36750435-20190217014734

so... with beowulf strenghthen, there are still 5 servants with this skill which is the most powercreeped skill in the game, followed by tactics and charisma (although the short CD on charisma makes it decent for the A and A+ ranks). i guess the reason for it to be such a bad skill aside from having skills and CEs that can regenerate stars over time is, instant stars can be good as secondary effects for some clutch situations (like the ones dantes, cleo, lalter, assasin li, saberlot and others have) but on its own its just underwhelming, unless it was a stupid larege amount like mozarts 3rd skill that can help secure a crit. there are certain situations that 10-15 stars can help, but its too much investment to be minimally decent, and still too niche.

now onto the ones left and what could be done:

chichiue: add guts. done, she is top tier AOE saber now. what? thats what everyone says, and its kinda ok i guess (although she only had this back in apocrypha thanks to her master, dont if this will procede)

edgy seiba: i honestly would rather upgrade her charisma but... maybe add ignore invul or apply curse on atacks? i dont know

lily seiba: add 10-20% atk buff to the whole party and heals them for 1-2k (i think it would be nice for her to play kindalike a pseudo-support, since in her young age she leading and ralling people to fight alongside her)

husbando seiba: increase own atk 15-25% 3 turns, removes own debuffs, increase stars by 5.

christmas seiba: increase critical strenght 20-30% 1 turn (actually she makes good use of this skill because of her high star weight as a rider, but i guess people still think this skill sucks am i rght?)