Talk:Ryougi Shiki (Saber)/@comment-112.215.244.240-20180214175946/@comment-28209103-20180219050916

I don't think we could even compare Shiki passive to others servant in the first place, as I said she is just case of exception where her passive can be read as "6% buff to all stat" and this does not apply to other servant passive, even those with 2 performance passive like Raikou cannot be called that she received a stat boost because the non-uniform number and the incomplete coverage and as you said it'll never end.

Generalizing thing without basis is bad but not seeing exception as an exception is also a mistake. The thing is you need to be able to differentiate exception and the norm and able to recognize that the normal way does not apply to exception and vice versa.

now when in the future we'll get a servant with all cards performance buff but at different number then we're talking, that'll be most exceptional case of exception that are pretty hard to grasp with rough number however we don't need that for Shiki case because her buff are uniform across the board hence can be translated as 6% buff on everything she does (unless you wanna stick to that extra cards,, but then again it's just an "extra")

also as you said it is component of stat however in Shiki case her passive cover every stat known in servant with exception of star absorb.. also I insist that we see a servant in case by case basis with holistic approach otherwise it'll be just a case of bias vs bias. It's like how you view independency as good quality while I saw it as a negative quality based on all the servant I studied thus far.