Talk:"The Old Man of the Mountain"/@comment-43819806-20190914055314/@comment-34208015-20190915232757

Thanks for defining comparaison criteria it'll help to show you why you are wrong.

> Considering all of that, what about Nitocris NP? She had the exact same effect before interlude and no one’s saying her NP is bad even then.

Pre interlude Nitocris NP is also kinda crappy from my point of view, she got the bare minimum like KH but what is the difference between KH and Nitocri already? Ah yes, Nitocris NP is AOE, she is a farming servant and instant death is much more powerful in farming context than in a CQ context.

> And what about the hit count? I see no problem with a buster NP having a one hit count. After all, not everyone can take advantage of multi-hit buster NPs to generate stars.

Hum so you would prefer a NP with lower hit count than one with higher hit count? Regardless if for you having lower hit-count is problematic or not, it objectively worst than the same NP with lower hit count. Full stop.

> What about quick NPs with one hit count? Are they problematic too because they can’t generate stars?

Don't know why you bring Quick up here, but if it can help to prove that I'm not biased in my analysis, I would consider that Scathach NP is about as crappy as KH NP if I discard her NP interlude and her 500% stun chance.