Talk:SE.RA.PH/@comment-29027964-20170511024554/@comment-49.228.125.65-20170511052936

Not really a Melt fan here,  But I'm Hayami fan so that could relate somewhat. And I rolled Melt because of Hayami voice alone so I couldn't careless about her gameplay. Even with all the reasons I still find the analysis unnatural.

Lip:  She is not as tanky as you make her to be. If you use all her skills at once then yes she will be very tanky for 1 turn. But with all of her skill having differrent CD it will be hard to use them all the second time because you will have to wait for longest CD to reset. Having BBB makes her hit hard but that also makes it harder to charge her NP and also harder to heal using NP.

Melt and Kiara:  I can't comment much about Kiara because I havn't used her in real fight yet, so I will use your point here. First you said that Kiara is not to be comepared with the best buffer like Waver and Merlin, in this point she is forgiven. Then you said that she can't compare to Shuten the best debuffer, in this point she is also forgiven. Then for Melt you said that she is not as good as the best buster DPS like Jeane and Cu and also short from the best quick DPS like Jack and Shishou. Alright Jack is the top servant in term of NP spam and star generating and Shishou is the top servant in term of NP. Yet now for Melt not being able to be the same class as these top servant, unlike in Kiara's case, you find it unforgivable, I really can't see your standard here. Then in term of survivalbility, everyone who play F/GO long enough knows that per hit evade are more usefull than per turn evade in "most" situations not just "some" situation as you said. Her second skill lower her defence 10% for 3 turns but her first skill also gives her evade for 3 turn, unless she is hit more than 2 times she is not going to take damage during that period. And both skill have the same CD making them easier to use unlike Lip's skills. About star absorb that you said that you said she might not get all of them. Melt being crit servant and support DPS as you said, you will want to put her together with main DPS which is likely a quick type. And in team like that you will probably set up so that the team has at least 30 stars every turn, so I don't see a major problem.

I don' know what you think of why you always analyse in this direction when it comes to Melt. But reading your comment it does feel like you need Melt to meet higher standard than when you talk about other servants.