Thread:EnderShadowr215/@comment-35402059-20190326004800/@comment-24503208-20190326014807

WitchofMiracles wrote: I did. Admittedly HF Shirou was alright(At in comparsions to the other routes). Can't exactly trash that version of him as much. But that is just 1/3 of the VNs. For the other 2/3, that annoying high schooler is all you will get imo. Fate route Shirou is probably the hardest one to enjoy, cause his hypocrisy has been raised up to 11 and he spent half of the time being a dick to Saber(and in general, cause I think that route was when he made a reply about being molested would teach someone humility). UBW is more of how much the plot bent over so he can actually said but I don't want to go into that rn. I'm probably rambling, but I trying to stay positive while talking about Shirou so I can keep a clear head.

Hmmm being a dick to Saber does seem a tad bit far fetched given how anyone can literally take any scene(s) and statement(s) out of context.

In addition to that, which scene that has Shirou saying that regarding being molested will teach you humility? Because that seems out of character and stupid even for him.

Hmmm tbf in all three routes, it was mentioned or implied that Shirou has no experience with the Holy Grail plus he was not fully taught by Kitisuga Emiya before his adoptive father’s death.

Hell you can really chalked that up as Fate route Shirou not getting completely used to having a Servant at first.

Also in addition to that, I don’t recall Fate route Shirou being that much of a dick to Saber since that is basically just ignore all the scenes that show their relationship to that of being friends.

Hell even it is not like Shirou can directly take on Berserker Heracles head-on as that is basically asking for a sucide attack although I recall that Shirou did eventually help Saber against Berserker by tracing a special sword IIRC.