Talk:Ryougi Shiki (Saber)/@comment-112.215.244.240-20180214175946/@comment-30522333-20180218190338

A good reviewer does, in fact, evaluate everything. Damage output, NP generation, stars generation, as well as the servant's interaction with its own skills and passive that will further dictate the servant's playstyle and comfort zone/strengths/weaknesses. And no, it's not easy. Give a half-ass review, then people will rip it apart like no tomorrow.

You're not wrong in your statement of "Lowest Atk stats of all 5* Saber", but it's simply just that "ATK stats". This topic was opened as "STATS" and not simply "Atk stats". "Atk stats" is part of the servant's "STATS" and not the "be all end all" of the said servant.

And if we only judge a servant base on "ATK stats", Robin Hood will be the weakest 3-star archer, which is furthest from the truth. "ATK stats" will not deduce any type of value judgment, but actual "STATS" can and will. And if stats are not meant to be used to deduce any type of value judgment, then everything we said so far means complete rubbish, and we're just wasting time.

You need to understand, "ATK" "HP" "Base NP gen" "Passive bonus" "Stargen" "NP Damage" are all part of a servant's "STATS", "functions" to be used in damage/stargen/NPgen calculation by the game. They are Passive and always there.