Talk:William Tell/@comment-33784096-20190620045938/@comment-27971189-20190620083854

I think Taufu confused how it applies if he ever used modern weapons as his crossbow seems like replacable modern weapon, I presume. I'll just answer the second one, two and three.

1. No. See, William Tell has two things related to his aim. Apple Shooting and Aiming EX.

If he use modern crossbow, the one working is only Aiming EX while Apple Shooting is unique to his old crossbow as its part of his legend. Knight of Owner made this boundary clear, if you want to use your skill NP (in this case, Apple Shooting) the item should be defined as yours first.

Thus we never saw moments like Cu using his Gae Bolg throwing technique with a mop or Kojiro using Tsubame Gaeshi with baseball bat; that thing are not belong to them. Unless its specified otherwise, Apple Shooting is strictly belong to his original crossbow while for other projectile weapons like gun, he only be able to use Aiming EX.

What's the difference? To put it simply, Aiming EX is "up to 100% accuracy", while Apple Shooting is "guaranteed 100% accuracy".

2. Not working for reason I said above.

If Napoleon using modern cannon, the best he could got is increased damage potential from Fire Support and lucky moment from Light of Possibilities. The whole Anti-Divine constructs bonus still goes to cannon he brought with his Saint Graph.

Regarding your idea of disarming. It back to said Servant.

Having equipment-type NP not telling they're slouch when you disarm them.

Saber may powerless without Excalibur but there are people like Karna, Sigurd and Lancelot who can still kick your ass even if you disarm their weapons.

Having skill-type NP doesn't mean an easy win either because it'll bound to said Servant prime age, mental and physical condition also legends.

Thus we have case of various old man Li due to some Master aiming for ideal skill set for him or Berserker Lancelot that seems overpowered because being berserk made him forgot about his physical limitation and logical thinking.

I think old man Li is prime example of skill-type NP pro and con.

Younger got physical condition good but unrefined technique. Older got refined technique but not-so-good physical condition. What is the best catalysts to got both at the same time? Or did he really have  summonable version where he got both at the same time?