Talk:Scáthach/@comment-36459981-20190109013319/@comment-26162096-20190112164301

I get what you say. You just want her to stay at "below average - average" tier, outclassed even by 4* and grailled 3*.

>still very good against majority of Archers

So you admit that she isn't against ALL archers. Wow. Very stronk and effective.

Meanwhile really good servants like Gil (sometimes Tesla), Achilles, Jalter, archSeiba, KingHassan, Enkidu, Tamamo, Karna, Herk, Cu alter, MamaLanc, IbaraLanc, etc. doesn't even bother what an enemy class is.

>You can do the rest with Command Seal

You can't be serious about brinning CS in discussion about servant's strength, right? Right? Anyway, you know that with this thing (+CE) any servant can release it's np 4 times in row? But only once in 3 days. It's same for every servant, so it can't be used in compatring.

And as I wrote before, stop bring Skadi because she doesn't matter:

1. she provides nothing new to Scathach

2. Waver provided same charge with a bit different bufs, in most cases even more consistant than Skadi.

>Saying she's one of the effective star-gen target is incorrect

Just put casgil in party with her and and you will see that you are wrong. Still her quick cards would be awful, but it would be garantied 4-5 stars per card, not 2 stars. (while maximum for 2-hit cards is 6 stars)

>if she's truly that excellent by simple 100% star-gen, why ever need to proposing change of hit-count and even extended Quick buff duration?

Because it's one of few ways to make her great again by herself, not by support babysitters.