Talk:Okita Sōji/@comment-33477111-20181003173551/@comment-32825966-20181003180803

I won't disagree that Okita's kit could use some reworking (like a 3 turn star absorption for starters) but you are comparing different servants with different uses. Okita has 10.2% star gen with 2 5 hits quick cards while nyanta alter has 5.1% star gen with 2 3 hits quick cards. Just that alone should tell you that the ideal role for each one is really different.

Comparing skills is kinda hard too, nyanta will need higher star absorption because zerkers have extremely low star weight and the extra stars are also more important to nyanta since her stargen is so much lower. Quick for the whole party vs just yourself is just a matter of support vs pure offensive (I personally prefer my supports to just support). I'll admit you're right with her last skill but it's just a bonus since its main use should be to make them survive the enemy's np so its use should be quite limited.

Last, did you ever stop to compare np gain? Okita has really good np gain while nyanta alter, while better than vanilla nyanta is no jack or squirtoria.

I'm not saying nyanta alter is bad, I think she's great, but your standards for comparison are kinda off, like saying apples are not as good as oranges because you can't make orange juice out of them.