Talk:Fate/EXTELLA SP Campaign NicoNico LiveStream/@comment-28137023-20161024095720/@comment-28048698-20161026232354

@Kitsune Tamamo no Mae: If I remember correctly, it isn't confirmed if they are the same person or not. Both things are possible. In example, correct me if I'm wrong but in the game EMIYA/Extra talk about Shinji, saying something like "he looks like someone I know, however he isn't THAT Shinji" (not the same words, of course). And I think the same thing happen with Rin.

Also, let's remember how EMIYA hate being a Hero of Justice in Fate, however at the end of UBW he somewhat make peace with that. In the other hand, this EMIYA can be the same Emiya Shirou, but one who embraced his wish of being a hero, just like the Emiya Shirou from UBW.

@Hitsuji: I'm not 100% about what I'm going to say because the last time I've played Fate/Extra was like one or two years ago, however...

If I remember correctly it isn't possible to make a contract with Moon Cell. The Moon Cell only have power in the network. It's like a huge and powerful AI. Inside Moon Cell doesn't exist the souls of the Heroic Spirits (unlike the Throne of Heroes; in that place exist the souls of all of them). Moon Cell just record all the humanity's story, so in those records is written all about Cu Chulainn, Tamamo, Nero, etc.

Probably what happen with that EMIYA/Extra is something like he doing contract with the Counter Force (just like EMIYA/FSN) and his story being recorded by Moon Cell. That's all.

On the other hand, he is a Nameless Hero, however not like Sasaki Kojiro's real identity (he REALLY is a nameless hero, it's unknown what is his real name). It can be EMIYA/Fate and a Nameless Hero at the same time. Maybe the humanity doesn't remember our EMIYA by his name, but by his actions (so he's just a nameless hero), or maybe he just doesn't want to make you (the main character) know his name (just like happen at the beginning with Rin).

So... Yeah, in my opinion they are the same person. Maybe with a little different story. Also, it's almost impossible for two different heroic spirits to have the same look (yeah, we have "Saberfaces", but with different bodies and clothes, not a full copy & paste), the same abilities (maybe we have many heroes with Protection from Arrows, and many heroes with Battle Continuation, and many heroes with Divinity, but how many of them with the three of them at the same time?) and, more important, with the same Noble Phantasm? It's impossible. We have three coincidences with very little chances there at the same time. :P